Another artists under sajaegi suspicions + Ben comments on charting #1

Haeun - Shin Yong Jae

*Haeun is the artist and Shin Yong Jae is the name of the song

The song was released on Nov 6 and it failed to chart-in on the weekly chart in the first & second weeks

On the third week, it started charting on the weekly chart

Fourth week

Fifth week

Sixth week

Its Youtube views are 2.63M. Songs listened by non-fans have high Youtube views and his views are not comparable to his chart rank.

To compare the song's popularity, here's the weekly karaoke chart of Yoon Jong Shin's 'Like It' which was a massive hit.

 Yoon Jong Shin's 'Like It' started charting #69

His song started getting big and he charts much higher

On the third week, he's #15

On the fourth week, he's #6

However, Haeun's 'Shin Yong Jae' started charting #16 on the third week

On the second week, he's already #4

Haeun's agency has artists including Ben

=

Instiz: Another release that Melon seems to be manipulating after Ben

- They take us for fools ㅋㅋ

- Jang Deok Cheol, Nilo, and Shaun became more issued and they didn't get any punishment. So I think artists are starting to manipulate more and more...

- 4Men, Vibe, and Ben are already famous artists. I don't understand why they're trying to increase their digital results.

- JangNilShaun must be this company's role model

- If you accuse anyone of sajaegi, people are gonna call you an insecure idol fan

Article: Ben, "I cried because I charted #1 for the first time in 9 years since debut, Yoon Min Soo sent me a congratulating text"

Source: Sports Today via Nate

1. [+469, -45] Does she not know about the controversy or is she pretending to not know?

2. [+426, -40] Her graph was the same as Nilo, Shaun and Jang Deok Cheol's, though? Also her boyfriend is in the same agency as the three artists ㅋㅋ

3. [+345, -38] Didn't she do sajaegi?

4. [+100, -8] Rather than a sajaegi, it must be true that she must've paid a company to stream her song with multiple accounts. Ben's song became #1 between 12PM~2AM and the song was #1 during the entire dawn. If you know about the Melon chart, you'd know that it's impossible. Even a massive hit song can't beat boy group fandom's streaming at dawn. Popular female artists like IU and Jennie chart low at dawn and start rising in the morning. Unless it's a boy group, everybody should be charting low at that time. If she managed to beat them all and chart #1, it means that she must have more fans than the boy groups. Do you think it's true? I don't see the point of charting #1 by doing this. Maybe she thought people wouldn't be suspicious because she's more famous than Shaun and Jang Deok Cheol. I'm very disappointed. I used to like Ben's songs but she was blinded by short-term results and gained a flaw that will follow her for the rest of her career.

5. [+67, -11] Her song isn't even good to be charting #1...

6. [+66, -2] I didn't want to be suspicious but her graph was the same as Shaun and Jang Deok Cheol's. It doesn't make sense that she's charting higher at dawn.

7. [+60, -2] She's pretending like she doesn't know ㅋㅋ

8. [+55, -3] Her boyfriend must've wanted to make her happy ㅎㅎ Great boyfriend she got!